1912-2012: Historic photos document 100 years of changes at Mount Baker

by Dave Tucker, September 17, 2012

A wonderful photo of Mount Baker was taken in 1912 by  “E.D. Welsh” from the summit of Loomis Mountain. The sepia-toned print was found by USFS employee Leif Hazelet on the wall of the Koma Kulshan guard station, and was moved to the Sedro Woolley office for protection. The photograph clearly shows the much greater extent of the Easton and Squak glaciers, as well as documenting the presence of glacial ice just above the Scott Paul Trail, where there is no ice today. Welsh’s photograph is perhaps the earliest, and certainly the best, view of the south flank of the volcano. It clearly shows the ice-covered rim of Carmelo Crater at the summit plateau of Mount Baker.

The original 1912 photo, with signature at lower left. Click to enlarge. To see a much larger version, go here: http://www.pbase.com/nolock/image/74122700/original

Cascade mountain photographer John Scurlock was captivated by the photograph and

The 2012 replica photograph. Note signature! Copyright John Scurlock

recognized its historic value. He scanned Welsh’s masterpiece, and for a decade has wanted to reproduce the photo in the centennial year, 2012. We believe E.D. Welsh was a publicity photographer for Diehl Ford in Bellingham. (September 19- Welsh found? Headstone photo)

The 2012 photo, with annotations. Black line indicates approximate 1912 ice positions. Dave Tucker photo.

The 2012 photo, with annotations. Black line indicates approximate 1912 ice positions. Dave Tucker photo.

The 1912 photo was clearly taken in late summer, as there are few snow patches in meadows. The location of the photo was verified by John in a couple of aerial fly-bys of potential sites; there was little doubt that a site in the vicinity of the hard-to-reach, trail-less summit of Loomis Mountain was the spot.

The Commemorative Expedition’s successful route climbs the south side of Loomis. Note the fantastic U notch. The ascent route is on the left, fearsome descent on the right. Moral- if the elk didn’t go that way, maybe you should think twice!

How Welsh got there is a bit of a puzzle, but the route was doubtless arduous, especially with the bulky cameras of the day. Logging roads now reach within a half day’s bush bash of the summit, but in 1912, the route was a looooooooooong hike. Perhaps Welsh reached Loomis via Mazama Park on the Middle Fork Nooksack Trail, then hiked over Park Butte (no lookout in those days, and no trail) and along the rugged connecting ridge to Loomis. This was a multi-day trip from the nearest road at Heisler’s Ranch near today’s Mosquito Lake Road Bridge at the Middle Fork, but hopefully there was a pack-horse to carry loads at least as far as Park Butte. This was the route used by runners on the Easton Route of the Mount Baker marathon; 1912 was the second year of that unbelievable foot race; it is also possible that an old trail up the South Fork Nooksack from Lyman could have been used. An approach up Rocky Creek from Concrete and the Baker River would have been a tough haul over the treacherous bone-breaking surface of the Sulphur Creek lava flow.

A Google Maps topo map of Loomis Mountain is here; Loomis is at the ‘A’. Click on ‘terrain’.

The 2012 commemorative expedition

Lindsey. Nope, not lost, but damn hard to see where she’s going! John Scurlock photo.

On September 5th, 2012, MBVRC board members Dave Tucker, John Scurlock, Sue Madsen, and Doug McKeever, in cooperation with North Cascades Institute, undertook a photo re-creation effort which we call the 1912 -2012 Loomis/Welsh Centennial Expedition.   Our team, ten in number, also included Jessica Haag and Lindsey Frallic from NCI, Scott Linneman from WWU and his friend Jim Webster, Eric Steig from UW, and Keith Kemplin.  This first attempt to re-create Welsh’s scene was made via the long east ridge of Loomis, beginning at Wanlick Pass on Forest Road 12. This is the road that leads into the head of the South Fork Nooksack and the spur up to Blue Lake and Dock Butte. After several hours of steep old growth, brush, and a pleasant, but mostly view-less stroll along the forested ridge, our party of 10 was stymied by a sheer rocky notch. Negotiating the sharp gap and the short but steep rock climb on the other side didn’t seem feasible for the group, so we opted for a later attempt via the abandoned logging road in the Loomis Creek valley. Anyway, it was getting late and time for a cooling beer and recuperative dinner at Birdsview Brewery.

We found a bear skull, rib cage, and pelvis in the forest just below the highest meadows.

Seven of us from the original team returned on September 16. The party consisted of Dave Tucker, John Scurlock, Doug McKeever, Jessica Haag, Lindsey Frallic, Scott Linneman and Jim Webster. After an easy walk up the road to an elevation of 3200 feet,we took to the woods and then grassy hellebore meadows along the north side of Loomis Creek. We climbed up the steep

Beginning the ascent on September 16. The summit is on the right of the rocky skyline. John Scurlock photo.

mountainside to the 5000′ ridge just east of the summit; fortunately, there was a spider web of elk trails for much of the route. Along the way, we passed a bear skeleton in the steep forest. The view of Baker from the crest was fantastic, but we were clearly too far east. We had a print of the Welsh photo, and it was a simple matter of lining up landmark angles in the photo to get to the exact spot used by Welsh – the rocky 5598′ summit of Loomis Mountain. John and I dressed in a semblance of 1912 garb (well, whatever we had in our closets) to represent our versions of a (male) Welsh. We don’t even know that.

The upper meadow- grab a handful of bushes and hope they hold. John Scurlock photo.

Smooth going in the upper meadow. Doug (left) and John. Jessica Haag photo.

John set up his camera on a tripod and snapped many photos. The changes over the past 100 years are remarkable. All the glaciers, most notably the Easton, have receded – a lot. We know this already, but the ability to photo-document the recession with Welsh’s photos is remarkable. In 1912, clean, white-looking ice extended to 4700′ (1430 m) elevation, about 0.20 m (320 m) above the upper Rocky Creek suspension bridge on the Scott Paul Trail, and 0.62 miles (995 m) below the most current ice margin. In 1912, ice may well have extended further south, but we can’t differentiate the presumably rubble-covered glacier terminus in the photo. The Squak and Talum glaciers have also receded a long way, and ice has completely disappeared in the basin west of Crag View – in 1912, a glacial tongue extended to 5300′ (1615 m) elevation, now 0.8 miles (1,300 m) below the lowest ice remnant in this basin, and 0.3 mile (480 m) above the Scott Paul trail where it crosses the boisterous stream at the moraine.  In 1912, a lobe of the Easton covered the site of “Sandy Camp”, where climbers camp in the boulder basin at the head of the Railroad Grade moraine. Other changes: now there is a lookout on Park Butte and roads snake up into the valleys. A recent fire has burned the south face of Survey Point, on the ridge south-east of Park Butte. After a really steep bushwhack descent via a different route, we toasted our success at the Trainwreck Tavern in Burlington.

The MBVRC / NCI Loomis-Welsh Commemorative Expedition. Left to right: John Scurlock, Jessica Haag, Lyndsey Frallic, Scott Linneman, Doug McKeever,Dave Tucker, Jim Webster, and Jasper the wonder dog. J. Scurlock photo.

JS and DT in replica garb at the summit. We found the bottle on the summit.

DT knew we had the right spot when landmarks in the 1912 photo aligned with our view. Jim Webster photo.

John sets up the 2012 recreation of Welsh’s photo. Jessica Haag photo.

The photographic expedition was a remarkable experience, and we all felt a connection with an obscure but important event in the scientific and cultural history of Mount Baker. This is such an awe-inspiring view. It is similar to the view from Park Butte, but much more expansive and from a higher elevation.

Our summit register note, commemorating the expedition.

 

Now, we just have to get back down through the woods, threading the needle between a sheer cliff and a really nasty gully. Brush rappels saved the day. Now, about those beers…

Advertisements

Responses

  1. […] 100 years of glacial recession  at Mount Baker. The story is told elsewhere on this blog: go here to read it and see the photos. A future post will highlight some of the changes in the past 100 […]

  2. Great stories and photo. Love the bottle find and the replica clothes – good job!

  3. I believe I may have found your photographer, E.D. Welsh. As an amateur genealogist with an Ancestry.com subscription, I did a search through census records around 1910-1920, but no luck. It then occurred to me that this photographer would have likely registered for the WWI draft. Searching the draft records I found the following:

    Emil Derixon Welsh born March 18, 1881 lived in Bellingham in 1918 and worked for the Diehl Simpson Company in Bellingham in “Advertising and Salesman”.

    I would bet this is your guy. If you want more information, let me know – I have saved the info I found at Ancestry. (and now that I have his name, there is likely more info available at Ancestry as well)

  4. A little more info I have since found: Emil Welsh died in 1962 and is buried at Bayview Cemetery in Bellingham.

  5. […] the photographer who took the photo from Loomis Mountain in 1912. (see the original article here).  Kelly wrote to the MBVRC blog today (September 19) with this […]

  6. After doing some more research, the Diehl Simpson Co. Welsh worked for later became Diehl Ford in Bellingham. Maybe the photo was taken by Welsh for a personal collection, but it could have been taken for use by the Diehl Simpson dealership in advertising materials or even displayed at the dealership itself. I won’t fill up your comment section with anything more – will wait to hear back from someone if you are interested in any more info on the probable photographer.

  7. Awesome story

  8. […] making a series of comparative photos showing glacial changes in the Cascades. He came across the Loomis-Baker comparison photos taken by E.D. Welsh (1912) and John Scurlock (2012) and posted on the MBVRC website a couple of […]

  9. […] making a series of comparative photos showing glacial changes in the Cascades. He came across the Loomis-Baker comparison photos taken by E.D. Welsh (1912) and John Scurlock (2012) and posted on this website a couple of months […]

  10. Wonderful! Thank you!

  11. I hiked the east ridge from NF-12 on Oct 23/15. The notch is tricky but there is an exposed ledge on the north side (still class 3 terrain though). Great views of Mount Baker from the summit along with the Twin Sisters Range. The JD bottle is still in the summit cairn.

    • Simon, Thanks for this report. Yes, it is possible to get by the notch on the north, but we had a large party and too dicey for some.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: